12 Gothic & Supernatural Netflix Shows to Watch in 2025 If You Loved Wednesday

If you loved Wednesday’s gothic charm, deadpan humor, and supernatural mysteries, these Netflix picks will scratch the same itch in 2025. From teen sleuths at haunted schools to sardonic witches and brooding detectives, here are the best shows like Wednesday—with quick reasons to watch, key similarities, and watch links.

Quick Picks (at a glance)

Tip: Start with Dead Boy Detectives (light, witty mysteries) or Lockwood & Co. (ghosty fun + British banter) if you want the most Wednesday-adjacent tone.

The List (with similarities & links)

1) Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (2018) — Supernatural Horror, Teen Drama

Magic, mischief, and a witch academy. Sabrina splits life between a normal high school and the Academy of Unseen Arts, juggling family curses, occult rituals, and razor-sharp quips.
Similarities: goth teen heroine · boarding-school vibes · dark humor + horror · family secrets
Watch: on Netflix

2) Dead Boy Detectives (2024) — Supernatural Mystery, Dark Fantasy

Two deceased British teens refuse the afterlife to run a ghost detective agency with a living clairvoyant friend. Spooky cases, sardonic banter, and heart.
Similarities: teen sleuthing · ghosts/demons/witches · witty morbid tone · case-of-the-week energy
Watch: on Netflix

3) A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder (2024) — Teen Mystery Thriller

A brilliant student reopens a small-town cold case. No supernatural here, but the Wednesday-style obsession and twisty reveals deliver.
Similarities: school setting · sharp outsider heroine · secrets & suspects · noir teen vibe
Watch: on Netflix

4) Lockwood & Co. (2023) — Supernatural Adventure, Teen Thriller

In a ghost-plagued London, three talented teens run their own paranormal agency—iron rapiers, haunted houses, and dry British humor included.
Similarities: teen ghost hunts · haunted mansions · mystery arc · witty, deadpan camaraderie
Watch: on Netflix

5) The Midnight Club (2022) — Horror Drama, Teen Mystery

Terminally ill teens form a secret club to trade scary stories and decode their hospice’s occult past. Touching and eerie in equal measure.
Similarities: midnight investigations · secret society vibes · ghostly encounters · dark humor with heart
Watch: on Netflix

6) Riverdale (2017) — Teen Mystery, Dark Soap

Starts as a murder mystery; later seasons lean gleefully gothic and bizarre (witches, cults, timelines). Campy, chaotic, addictive.
Similarities: school conspiracies · noir narration · occult flourishes · misfit squad vs. corrupt adults
Watch: on Netflix

7) The Sandman (2022–2025) — Dark Fantasy, Gothic Drama

Epic, literary gothic fantasy where Dream repairs his realm of nightmares. Not a teen show, but drenched in macabre elegance and mystery.
Similarities: sumptuous gothic worlds · sardonic tone · occult quests · iconic supernatural cast
Watch: on Netflix

8) School Spirits (2023– ) — Teen Supernatural Mystery

A teen wakes up dead and stuck on campus; with a living friend and ghostly support group, she investigates her own murder.
Similarities: school + afterlife twist · snarky heroine · friend-group sleuthing · layered whodunit
Watch: on Netflix

9) Stranger Things (2016– ) — Sci-Fi Horror, Ensemble Teen Adventure

Misfit kids, monsters from the Upside Down, and secret labs. Horror and humor with enormous heart and momentum.
Similarities: teen outsiders vs. supernatural threat · mystery-driven arcs · found family · retro flair
Watch: on Netflix

10) The Umbrella Academy (2019– ) — Quirky Superhero Fantasy, Dark Comedy

Seven damaged siblings with bizarre powers reunite in a gothic mansion to stop the apocalypse—again.
Similarities: dysfunctional spooky family · deadpan humor · murder mysteries & conspiracies · stylish set-pieces
Watch: on Netflix

11) Legacies (2018–2022) — Supernatural Teen Drama, Fantasy

At the Salvatore School, witches, wolves, and vampires face a monster-of-the-week (and plenty of prophecies).
Similarities: supernatural academy · strong female lead · ancient magic & grimoires · campy, self-aware fun
Watch: on Netflix

12) The Haunting of Hill House (2018) — Gothic Horror, Family Drama

A prestige haunted-house saga about grief, memory, and the ghosts we carry. Chilling and deeply emotional.
Similarities: peak gothic atmosphere · ancestral secrets · visions/hauntings · slow-burn mystery
Watch: on Netflix

How we chose (for the best Google results)

• Search intent match: Focus on “shows like Wednesday” with gothic + teen + supernatural + mystery overlap.
• Freshness for 2025: Includes trending or still-relevant titles with ongoing fandom interest.
• Skimmability: Quick-pick table, bolded similarities, short watch links.
• AEO/FAQ: Answer-style sections and structured data below.

FAQs

What should I watch after Wednesday on Netflix in 2025?

Start with Dead Boy Detectives (supernatural sleuthing) or Lockwood & Co. (teen ghost hunters). If you want witch-academy vibes, pick Chilling Adventures of Sabrina.

Which show is most similar to Wednesday’s humor?

Dead Boy Detectives and Lockwood & Co. balance eerie cases with witty, deadpan banter closest to Wednesday’s tone.

Is there a school like Nevermore?

Yes—Legacies (Salvatore School) and Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (Academy of Unseen Arts) deliver the supernatural-academy feel.

I want pure gothic horror, less teen drama—what’s best?

Go for The Haunting of Hill House (prestige gothic) or The Sandman (mythic, poetic dark fantasy).